Counterpoint - The Journal of Science and the Law
  • Home
    • About Us
    • Seminars
    • Contact
    • Submissions
    • Terms
    • Privacy
  • Free Previews
    • Free1: 9000 RADS
    • Free2: 9000 Specificity
    • Free3: 9000 RFI
    • Free4: PBT COVID
    • Free5: NYT
    • Free6: NPR
    • Sample - Forensic Encyclopedia
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribers
    • DUIDLA >
      • Subscribe DUIDLA
    • Volume Seven >
      • Vol 7 Iss 1 Art 1 CNS Trauma
      • Vol 7 Iss 1 Art 2 New Alcohol Use
    • Volume 6 >
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 1 IR Part1
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 2 IR Part2
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 3 IR Specificity
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 4 Cannabis-Driving
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 5 DUI Investigations
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 6 Reliability
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 1 BBR2022
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 2 Fuel Cells
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 3 PBTs
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 4 Evidentiary 1
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 5 Evidentiary 2
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 6 Retro 1-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 1 Retro 2-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 2 Metric-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 3 Bell-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 4 Suitability
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 5 Altitude
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 6 Stages of Impairment
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 1 DUI Technology
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 2 Long COVID
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 3 False Refusals
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 4 Scientific Literacy
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 5 Small Stature
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 6 ISO ASD
    • Volume 5 >
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 1 Ethanol
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 2 Standard Drinks
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 3 Dissipation
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 4 PEth
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 5 SFSTs
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 6 Corruption
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 1 GERD1
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 2 GERD2
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 3 IRP
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 4 Gastric Bypass
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 5 Absorption 2021
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 6 Standard THC Dose
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 1 Video Evidence
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 2 Distribution
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 3 Circadian
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 4 Spiked
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 5 GHB
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 6 Tolerance
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 1 Language
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 2 Long Haulers
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 3 ABHS BAT
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 4 Metabolism2021
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 5 COVID-Fall 2021
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 6 Inhalers
    • Volume 4 >
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 1 THC-Opioid
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 2 CBD-Opioid
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 3 Cannabis-Opioid
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 4 Breath Basics
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 5 Widmark
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 6 NYT Cowley
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 1 NPR-1A
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 2 - Rx
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 3 - Holiday Drinking
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 4 - Hangover 1
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 5 - Hangover 2
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 6 - Forensics
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 1 - Fingerprint 1
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 2 - COVID-19
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 3 - Sanitizers
      • Corona Anxiety
      • Downtime
      • Remote Work
      • Corona Mental Health
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 4 - RFI
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 5 - MIDMT
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 6 - PBT COVID
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 1 - Covid Effects
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 2 - Covid Cognitive Decline
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 3 - EtG
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 4 - DRE1
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 5 - Trials
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 6 - COVID Mental Health
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 7 - COVID Mental Health Tips
    • Volume 3 >
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 1 Wait Periods
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 2 Slope1
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 3 Slope2
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 4 Slope 3
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 5 Henry's Law
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 6 C-46
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 1 Discovery1
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 2 Discovery2
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 3 Discovery 3
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 4 Expert 1
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 5 Expert 2
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 6 Expert 3
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 1 - Case Study 1
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 2 - Case Study 2
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 3 -CT
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 4 Physio1
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 5 Physio2
      • Vol 3, Iss 3, Art 6 - Aging Drivers
      • Vol 3, Iss 4, Art 1-Fake News
      • Vol 3, Iss 4, Art 2-5000-1
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 3 - Cannabidiol
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 4 - CT
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 5 C-46
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 6 - MN-DMT
    • Volume 2 >
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 1 COPD
      • Vol 2; Iss. 1 - Art 2 Drug Court
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 3 Calibration
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 4 Collaboration
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 5 Diabetes
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 6 Best Practice 1 1
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 1 - Best Practice 2
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 2 - Mental Health
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 3 - 9000 RADS
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 4 - 9000 Specificity
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 5 - 9000 RFI
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 6 - Sleepiness
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 1 - Experts
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 2 - Sampling Logistics
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 3 - Test Subjects
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 4 - Treatment Differences
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 5 - Error Message Part 1
      • Vol 2, Iss 3; Art 6 - Error Messages Part 2
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 1 - Deficient Errors
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 2 - Invalid Sample
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 3 - THC
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 4 - Diabetes 2
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 5 - HGN
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 6 SCRAM
    • Forensic Encyclopedia
  • The DUI Mastery Series
    • Core Skills >
      • Core Skills I >
        • CS I-1
        • CS I-2
        • CS I-3
        • CS I-4
        • CS I-5
        • Core Skills I Complete
      • Core Skills II >
        • CS II-1
        • CS II-2
        • CS II-3
        • CS II-4
        • CS II-5
    • Foundational Skills >
      • Foundational Skills I >
        • FS I-1
        • FS I-2
        • FS I-3
        • FS I-4
        • FS I-5
      • Foundational Skills II >
        • FS II-1
        • FS II-2
        • FS II-3
        • FS II-4
        • FS II-5
    • Advanced Skills >
      • Advanced Skills I >
        • AS I-1
        • AS I-2
        • AS I-3
        • AS I-4
        • AS I-5
      • Advanced Skills II >
        • AS II-1
        • AS II-2
        • AS II-3
        • AS II-4
        • AS II-5
    • Mastery Skills >
      • Mastery Skills I >
        • MS I-1
        • MS I-2
        • MS I-3
        • MS I-4
        • MS I-5
      • Mastery Skills II >
        • MS II-1
        • MS II-2
        • MS II-3
        • MS II-4
        • MS II-5
Picture

NPR Interview with Joshua Johnson

An interview with New York Times reporter Jessica Silver-Greenberg, Attorney Joseph Bernard & Counterpoint Editor Jan Semenoff

From - Counterpoint Volume 4; Issue 2 - Article 1 (November 2019)

One of the most interesting effects of the 2019 New York Times article "These Machines Can Put You in Jail. Don't Trust Them." by Stacy Cowley and Jessica Silver Greenberg, is the national media attention it received.
I started receiving requests from reporters for interviews and quotations. I participated in a panel discussion with New York Times reporter Jessica Silver Greenberg and Massachusetts attorney Joseph Bernard. The link below takes you to NPR's nation-wide show "1A" with host Joshua Johnson. It is well worth the time to listen (about 35 minutes).
Click here to listen to the broadcast online.

Click here to go to NPR's "1a" podcast. 
​Jessica Silver-Greenberg:
"We found that the machines are often unreliable and that they generate skewed results whether too high or too low with alarming frequency."

Joseph Bernard:
"We discovered in Massachusetts the maintenance and calibration of these machines was done without protocol... This puts 27,000 cases at risk because of the delicate balance that goes into calibrating these machines."

Picture

    Question? Comments? Start the conversation here:

Submit
Send me your questions or comments:
​

Comments and questions will be posted here with their responses:
Daniel Donahue, NC, USA:
I listened to the interview on 1A today. I was very interested in hearing a more elaborate response to Wayne, the North Carolina officer, who claimed that the results of all his tests were reliable. Have you ever published articles or done studies on the Intoximeters, Inc. EC/IR II? I'm a NC practitioner and find the calibration methods, inter alia, to be highly questionable.


Thanks for all your work.
From the Editor:
Daniel, as you are aware, access to breath test devices is problematic to near impossible for independent experts. I'm factory certified as a Calibration Technician and Operator of the EC/IR II breath testing device. We do have generic articles on the Calibration (Counterpoint, Volume 2, Issue 1) of breath test devices, but nothing specific to the EC/IR II. 
- Jan

Picture
Counterpoint is a publication of:
Industrial Training & Design Ltd.
© MMXXIII Counterpoint Journal.
​All Rights Reserved.

​Call Toll-Free: 1-888-470-6620
  • Home
    • About Us
    • Seminars
    • Contact
    • Submissions
    • Terms
    • Privacy
  • Free Previews
    • Free1: 9000 RADS
    • Free2: 9000 Specificity
    • Free3: 9000 RFI
    • Free4: PBT COVID
    • Free5: NYT
    • Free6: NPR
    • Sample - Forensic Encyclopedia
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribers
    • DUIDLA >
      • Subscribe DUIDLA
    • Volume Seven >
      • Vol 7 Iss 1 Art 1 CNS Trauma
      • Vol 7 Iss 1 Art 2 New Alcohol Use
    • Volume 6 >
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 1 IR Part1
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 2 IR Part2
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 3 IR Specificity
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 4 Cannabis-Driving
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 5 DUI Investigations
      • Vol 6 Iss 1 Art 6 Reliability
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 1 BBR2022
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 2 Fuel Cells
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 3 PBTs
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 4 Evidentiary 1
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 5 Evidentiary 2
      • Vol 6 Iss 2 Art 6 Retro 1-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 1 Retro 2-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 2 Metric-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 3 Bell-22
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 4 Suitability
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 5 Altitude
      • Vol 6 Iss 3 Art 6 Stages of Impairment
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 1 DUI Technology
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 2 Long COVID
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 3 False Refusals
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 4 Scientific Literacy
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 5 Small Stature
      • Vol 6 Iss 4 Art 6 ISO ASD
    • Volume 5 >
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 1 Ethanol
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 2 Standard Drinks
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 3 Dissipation
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 4 PEth
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 5 SFSTs
      • Vol 5 Iss 1 Art 6 Corruption
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 1 GERD1
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 2 GERD2
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 3 IRP
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 4 Gastric Bypass
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 5 Absorption 2021
      • Vol 5 Iss 2 Art 6 Standard THC Dose
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 1 Video Evidence
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 2 Distribution
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 3 Circadian
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 4 Spiked
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 5 GHB
      • Vol 5 Iss 3 Art 6 Tolerance
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 1 Language
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 2 Long Haulers
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 3 ABHS BAT
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 4 Metabolism2021
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 5 COVID-Fall 2021
      • Vol 5 Iss 4 Art 6 Inhalers
    • Volume 4 >
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 1 THC-Opioid
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 2 CBD-Opioid
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 3 Cannabis-Opioid
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 4 Breath Basics
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 5 Widmark
      • Vol 4 Iss 1 Art 6 NYT Cowley
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 1 NPR-1A
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 2 - Rx
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 3 - Holiday Drinking
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 4 - Hangover 1
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 5 - Hangover 2
      • Vol 4 Iss 2 Art 6 - Forensics
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 1 - Fingerprint 1
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 2 - COVID-19
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 3 - Sanitizers
      • Corona Anxiety
      • Downtime
      • Remote Work
      • Corona Mental Health
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 4 - RFI
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 5 - MIDMT
      • Vol 4 Iss 3 Art 6 - PBT COVID
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 1 - Covid Effects
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 2 - Covid Cognitive Decline
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 3 - EtG
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 4 - DRE1
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 5 - Trials
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 6 - COVID Mental Health
      • Vol 4 Iss 4 Art 7 - COVID Mental Health Tips
    • Volume 3 >
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 1 Wait Periods
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 2 Slope1
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 3 Slope2
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 4 Slope 3
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 5 Henry's Law
      • Vol 3 Iss 1 Art 6 C-46
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 1 Discovery1
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 2 Discovery2
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 3 Discovery 3
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 4 Expert 1
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 5 Expert 2
      • Vol 3 Iss 2 Art 6 Expert 3
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 1 - Case Study 1
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 2 - Case Study 2
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 3 -CT
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 4 Physio1
      • Vol 3 Iss 3, Art 5 Physio2
      • Vol 3, Iss 3, Art 6 - Aging Drivers
      • Vol 3, Iss 4, Art 1-Fake News
      • Vol 3, Iss 4, Art 2-5000-1
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 3 - Cannabidiol
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 4 - CT
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 5 C-46
      • Vol 3, Iss4, Art 6 - MN-DMT
    • Volume 2 >
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 1 COPD
      • Vol 2; Iss. 1 - Art 2 Drug Court
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 3 Calibration
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 4 Collaboration
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 5 Diabetes
      • Vol 2; Iss 1 - Art 6 Best Practice 1 1
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 1 - Best Practice 2
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 2 - Mental Health
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 3 - 9000 RADS
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 4 - 9000 Specificity
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 5 - 9000 RFI
      • Vol. 2, Iss 2; Art 6 - Sleepiness
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 1 - Experts
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 2 - Sampling Logistics
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 3 - Test Subjects
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 4 - Treatment Differences
      • Vol. 2, Iss 3; Art 5 - Error Message Part 1
      • Vol 2, Iss 3; Art 6 - Error Messages Part 2
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 1 - Deficient Errors
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 2 - Invalid Sample
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 3 - THC
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 4 - Diabetes 2
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 5 - HGN
      • Vol 2, Iss 4; Art 6 SCRAM
    • Forensic Encyclopedia
  • The DUI Mastery Series
    • Core Skills >
      • Core Skills I >
        • CS I-1
        • CS I-2
        • CS I-3
        • CS I-4
        • CS I-5
        • Core Skills I Complete
      • Core Skills II >
        • CS II-1
        • CS II-2
        • CS II-3
        • CS II-4
        • CS II-5
    • Foundational Skills >
      • Foundational Skills I >
        • FS I-1
        • FS I-2
        • FS I-3
        • FS I-4
        • FS I-5
      • Foundational Skills II >
        • FS II-1
        • FS II-2
        • FS II-3
        • FS II-4
        • FS II-5
    • Advanced Skills >
      • Advanced Skills I >
        • AS I-1
        • AS I-2
        • AS I-3
        • AS I-4
        • AS I-5
      • Advanced Skills II >
        • AS II-1
        • AS II-2
        • AS II-3
        • AS II-4
        • AS II-5
    • Mastery Skills >
      • Mastery Skills I >
        • MS I-1
        • MS I-2
        • MS I-3
        • MS I-4
        • MS I-5
      • Mastery Skills II >
        • MS II-1
        • MS II-2
        • MS II-3
        • MS II-4
        • MS II-5